Showing posts with label Trump. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Trump. Show all posts

Saturday, September 18, 2021

Useless Protest

 As most of you know, today there's a rally (again) in Washington DC, this one aimed at "Justice for January 6"...meaning the protestors want all those arrested or charged in the events of that date in the Capitol released and charges dismissed, on the grounds that they broke no laws since they were operating on "orders" from the Commander-in-Chief.

First of all, the President's role as C-in-C only applies to members of the military. He cannot give "orders" to ordinary citizens except through signed executive orders or, more usually, properly enacted legislation.

Second, even with the military, orders that require violation of the law--such as assaulting police officers, breaking-and-entering, interfering with Congress in the fulfillment of its duties--are not legal orders.

And third, what in hell makes these people think that a few hundred (or even a few thousand) people showing up in DC is going to make the Justice Department, the DC district attorney, or any other legal entity change its mind about what happened on January 6? These people have a strange overestimation of their own importance and power in the scheme of things--perhaps brought on by their deranged leader's insistence that they are merely the vanguard of the majority of Americans who agree with them.

This protest is useless, without avail, and is only likely to result in more arrests.

Saturday, February 13, 2021

Vote-ee-Oh-Doh

 I'm not going to comment on the arguments made by Trump's defense team yesterday for two reasons:

1. I didn't watch all of them.

2. From what I have seen, there was little there to comment on.

I am going to make a sort-of prediction, though. First, what should happen: There should be a unanimous vote to convict. After all, 98 of the jurors were actually witnesses to the events in question. (The two Senators from Georgia had not yet been seated on January 6.) But we cannot reasonably expect that outcome.

What I'd like to have happen: I'd like to see Trump convicted by a vote of around 70-30. I can't honestly expect more than about 20 Republicans to vote with the Democrats.

What will happen: Trump will be acquitted by a vote of around 40-60. I think there are 10 Republican Senators who, allowed to vote their conscience, will vote to convict. Which ones? I think we can count on Collins, Murkowski, Romney, and Toomey. I think Cassidy and McConnell are possibles. I leave the other four to your choices.


Wednesday, February 10, 2021

Not Exactly Perry Mason

 I dipped in and out of the coverage of the Senate trial yesterday, so I didn't see the entirety of any one lawyer's presentation, but parts of all of them. And while I think the House managers put on a case that would have done Law & Order's Jack McCoy proud, Trump's defense team was an embarrassment to every trial lawyer in the country.

There's an old saying in defense law: "When the law is against you, pound the facts; when the facts are against you, pound the law; when the law and the facts are against you, pound the table." Well, Trump's team nearly broke the table pounding on it yesterday.

"This trial is unconstitutional, because Mr. Trump is no longer in office." Of course, the only reason the trial is being held after he left office is because Mitch McConnell, who was in charge of scheduling, refused to hold it before Trump left office. It could have begun as early as January 14, because the House approved the article of impeachment on January 13. And, anyway, to argue that Trump is now immune from facing charges made before he left office is tantamount to saying the embezzler cannot be tried for his crimes if he is fired before the trial begins (even if the charges are filed before that happens).

It is clear to me that even if the Republicans win in the trial (as it currently appears they will), they have lost in the court of public opinion. 


Wednesday, January 27, 2021

Constitutional?

 The Senate shall have the sole Power to try all Impeachments. When sitting for that Purpose, they shall be on Oath or Affirmation. When the President of the United States is tried the Chief Justice shall preside: And no Person shall be convicted without the Concurrence of two thirds of the Members present.

 

Judgment in Cases of Impeachment shall not extend further than to removal from Office, and disqualification to hold and enjoy any Office of honor, Trust or Profit under the United States: but the Party convicted shall nevertheless be liable and subject to Indictment, Trial, Judgment and Punishment, according to Law. [emphasis added]

The above is the entire text of the clause in Article I of the U.S. Constitution that sets out the role of the Senate in an impeachment trial. I bold-faced that one phrase because it is important in the context of the current trial of Donald Trump. There is nothing in the text that even suggests, let alone days outright, that an officer cannot be impeached and tried after leaving office...and it is clear that if he or she has left office, the punishment of disqualification remains available in the event of conviction.

Why is it important that this be true? Let's take it out of the context of a president, and make it another impeachable officer--say, Secretary of the Treasury. Our hypothetical Secretary Badguy is charged with actually embezzling from the U.S. Treasury. The evidence is clear, and the House votes for impeachment. But before the trial can begin, Mr. Badguy sees the handwriting on the wall and resigns. Is there now to be no recourse for the Congress? "Sorry, he's out of office, no point in trying him now." That would leave him unpunished and still eligible to be appointed, or worse, elected to another position in the future.

So, yes, it must be Constitutional to try an officeholder whose term has expired or who had resigned.


Wednesday, January 20, 2021

A New Beginning

What we saw today was in part a study in contrasts. In the space of under four hours, we heard two Presidents speak...one for his last time in that office (we hope) and one for his first time. The differences could not be more stark.

Although President Trump reportedly had prepared remarks for his farewell, he apparently tossed them out and decided to "wing it" in his usual disjointed, incoherent, self-aggrandizing style. His brief speech said little about anything but Donald Trump himself, extolling his non-existent accomplishments of the past four years, once again lying or exaggerating about the economy and the pandemic. 

On other hand, President Biden spoke from a prepared speech...but still far more from the heart than his predecessor had or ever has. I couldn't, of course, transcribe his entire speech (and that will be available within minutes from the media, I'm sure), but here are the sentences and phrases that caught my attention:

"This is democracy's day...."

"The American story depends on....all of us...."

"The dream of justice for all will be deferred no longer...."

"My whole soul is in this...uniting our nation...."

"Without unity there is no peace...."

"Disagreement need not lead to disunity...."

"We must end this uncivil war...."

"We will not lead merely by the example of our power, but by the power of our example...."

Beyond the new President's own words, I was moved by two other things. The first was Lady Gaga's incredible rendering of the National Anthem. She did not simply sing it, she performed it...with grand gestures and powerful emotion. The second was the poem by Andrea Gorman, the poet laureate, and her reading of it. It's clear her style develops from rap and hip-hop--the rhythms and rhymes of her work all reflect that--and yet it was also clearly not merely an urban, ethnic opus. Like Hamilton, it uses those tropes to speak to a wider audience.

This was an inaugural ceremony for our time.

Friday, January 15, 2021

Impeach Pit

 So the new argument is whether impeachment only makes things worse. The current assumption is that the Senate will not convict, leaving Trump free to continue his established ways, and his most rabid followers to virtually and literally attack those who opposed him.

This morning I heard a respected expert suggest a 9/11-style commission as a substitute. My first thought was that, today, almost ten years after 9/11, there remains a significant part of the American public that rejects the findings of that commission, that puts forward a range of conspiracies from the idea that the Twin Towers were collapsed by bombs and not the plane strikes, that the entire event was a "false flag" to justify Middle East intervention, and even that the planes never struck the towers and the Pentagon and all the video we have is fake (and the live broadcasts were a ruse that the networks were in on from the beginning).

Commissions and hearings just drag out the controversy and allow the fringe nuts to point to theories expounded in that testimony as "the real truth" or as evidence of whatever conspiracy they choose to accept.

Short of Trump dying (and I'm not even sure that would work, as there would surely be people who presume reports of his death are false--either perpetrated by his supporters or his detractors), I don't know how to end his influence on our politics in the short term. As was pointed out recently, Juan Peron died in 1974, but the movement he began in 1946 persists in modern Argentina.


Tuesday, January 12, 2021

Eight Days? A Week?

 I am torn as to what should be done in the remaining days of the Trump administration (eight left as of this morning). 

Clearly, the best thing is for Trump to resign--it's the fastest, requires no action on anyone else's part and takes effect immediately. But we all know that's not going to happen, at least not without some kind of metaphorical gun to his head.

Second best would be activating the provisions of the 25th Amendment, declaring him unfit to continue to serve. There are several problems with that: First, Vice President Pence has said he is opposed, so the simplest way to do it (the VP and cabinet voting for it) is not going to happen and any other method would take too long; second, the provisions outlined in the amendment's language seem to be largely directed toward health reasons and not criminal ones, which means there could be court fights over whether the amendment even applies; and third, the amendment allows the President to challenge the action in the courts, again delaying the effectiveness.

Third best is impeachment, which the House has taken the first steps towards. But until the two new Senators from Georgia are seated, the Senate remains with Republican majority. That's not expected to happen until Inauguration Day itself, so there couldn't be a successful vote to remove Trump until he was already out of office.

Eight days may not seem like a long time--especially now that so much of Trump's bully pulpit has come unplugged--but his most rabid followers, the ones who eagerly heard his words last Wednesday as permission for riot and insurrection, are tuned into him, no matter how he gets the message out. Eight days is more than sufficient for a dangerous conspiracy to continue.



Thursday, January 07, 2021

Coordinated Violence?

 Not sure how many people have seen this, since it hasn't been mentioned in any TV coverage I've seen, but the insurrection against the Capitol in Washington may not have been a standalone attack.

State capitals in at least six states--Utah, Oregon, Washington, Kansas, Texas, and Arkansas--were threatened by large, violent and armed mobs yesterday afternoon. While none of these incidents seems to have resulted in the sort of breech of security that occurred on Capitol Hill, all of them resulted in some disruption of normal activity--including lock-downs and evacuations. (https://thehill.com/homenews/state-watch/532997-state-capitals-under-siege-by-pro-trump-mobs)

Does anyone think this is all coincidental? That there was not some sort of coordination involved? That followers of QAnon and 4-Chan and the like did not put out a call, a signal, to their compatriots that the afternoon of January 6 was the time to rise up and take control? I am not that naive.

I've seen some commentary on line comparing yesterday's insurrection to the famed Gunpowder Plot that is commemorated in Guy Fawkes Day. I think that comparison is inapposite. I think it has more in common with the Beerhall Putsch of pre-Nazi Germany. (If you're unfamiliar with that historic incident, here's a link:  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Beer_Hall_Putsch)

Either way, we're talking an organized attempt to disrupt or overthrow the government.


Wednesday, January 06, 2021

Trump's Epiphany

It is perhaps significant that today's events in Washington fall on the Feast of the Epiphany. In the Christian church, this is the date on which the Magi arrived in Bethlehem, indicating Christ's manifestation to the Gentiles. But the word has a larger, more secular meaning as well:

an intuitive grasp of reality through something (such as an event) usually simple and striking; an illuminating discovery, realization, or disclosure

I'm hoping the failure of the last-ditch attempt to overrule and override the electoral results in Congress today will be an epiphany for Trump...or at least for his rabid followers--a grasp of reality, an illuminating realization that their ill-considered crusade is at an end. They lost in a fairly contested election in which there was no overwhelming voter fraud. (There's always some fraud--human nature practically demands it. Somebody somewhere is going to try to cheat.)

The question is, will this epiphany be the like the one Saul of Tarsus had on the road to Damascus--when he changed from persecuting Christians to leading them? Will Trump--or at least his followers--stop being perverters of democracy and become supporters of it?


Tuesday, January 05, 2021

Brick Walls and Rabbit Holes

 I have stopped trying to respond to people who insist that the election was "stolen" from Donald Trump. There's no point to it. You either wind up talking to a brick wall or following them down the rabbit hole of their own deluded thinking. Even when you present them with verifiable facts (with citations from multiple sources), they tell you it's all fake and part of the vast conspiracy. When you ask them to present verifiable evidence of their "truth," they fall back on the oldest conspiracist argument in the world: The fact that there is no evidence is the evidence of how big the conspiracy is. 

Early last year, before the pandemic, I directed a production of Neil Simon's The Prisoner of Second Avenue. I never thought the ravings of the lead character, Mel Edison, as he goes through a nervous breakdown would have any bearing on the real world, but....well, read the following and tell me it doesn't sound familiar if you've argued with a pro-Trumper or an anti-masker virus-denier in the past six months:

MEL: Do you want proof, Edna? Do you want me to give you actual, indisputable proof?

EDNA: Of what, Mel?

MEL: That me, that Dave Polichek, that Mike Ambrozi, Hal Chesterman, twenty-three secretaries, six point seven of the working force in this country today is unemployed not because of a recession, not because of wages and high prices, but because of a well organized, calculated, brilliantly executed plot? Do you want me to give you proof right here and now in this room?

EDNA: Well--alright...If you want, Mel. 

MEL: I CAN'T GIVE YOU ANY PROOF!! What kind of proof do I have? I'm out of work, that's my proof...They won't let me work!

 Let me point out that Simon wrote that in 1972, decades before Twitter and Facebook were even gleams in their creators' eyes.


Thursday, December 24, 2020

Pardon Me?

 I used to have a standard line I used when people would say, "Pardon me?" I would reply, "Who do you think you are, Richard Nixon?"

After this week, the number of political felons who would fit in that joke must be nearing a dozen...and may well double by the time we reach January 20. As I heard mentioned last night on MSNBC, this kind of flurry of pardons around the holidays is fairly common...but usually they are non-political: people who were given surprisingly harsh sentences, people who had clearly turned their lives around, people with health problems. 

There's one good thing that might come from all this--if any of the folks Trump pardoned in the last days of his term are called to testify about their role in his malfeasances, they can no longer claim the protections of the Fifth Amendment. The pardon means they cannot be prosecuted for their crimes, and hence they have no fear of incriminating themselves.


Wednesday, December 23, 2020

Crazy Like a Fox?

 Okay, so after months of avoiding any contact with the COVID relief efforts in Congress, now that they've passed--by a veto-proof majority--a minimal package that includes the necessary legislation to keep the government running for another few weeks, Trump decides it's not what he wanted (not that he told anyone what he wanted until now) and suggests he won't sign it.

Has this been his plan all along? To (1) blame Congress for not doing enough; and (2) hand Biden a government shut-down on January 20? "If I can't run the country, nobody gets to do it. Nyah-nyah, let's see you solve this one, wise guy!" And as for the prospect of a continued Republican majority in the Senate? "You're on your own, Mitch! I won't be here so I don't give a damn!"

Hasn't this been his pattern throughout his business career? Run a company into the ground, then declare bankruptcy or sell out to some poor sucker who doesn't realize how bad it really is, and leave it to others to suffer the consequences?

Is this just his biggest bankruptcy and abandonment?


Friday, November 13, 2020

Trump's End Game

 Today on Morning Joe, Joe Scarborough wondered why President Trump is continuing his hopeless fight to prove the election was rife with fraud. Paraphrasing a bit, he asked, "Why does the President prolong a story that only makes him look worse with every passing day? He wakes up every morning to a TV screen showing that his numbers either haven't changed or have gotten worse. If he would simply move on, we would do the same and another news story would be our lead."

It's a good question: What is Trump's goal in all this? Is it simply to prove to himself and his base that he is not a loser? That they were right to support him? If so, in the end, it does nothing of the kind. Poor losers are the worst kind of losers. Is it to hold his base together for a potential run again in 2024? In that time, his reputation will only be in further tatters. He will surely face criminal and civil charges in state and federal courts...and even if he wins or those charges are dismissed, his name and brand will be eternally tarnished. No matter how big his base, will the Republican Party be dumb enough to nominate a candidate with those kind of black marks? The negative ads write themselves.

Quite frankly, I don't understand it. 

I do understand why the GOP has, as a rule, not abandoned him to his fate. They hope to hold his base together long enough, at least, to win the two run-off Senatorial elections in Georgia, so that they can maintain at least a slim majority in the upper house. But that can't really be Trump's goal--if he's not going to be in the White House (and he's not), why should he give a damn who controls the Senate?

There's one other possibility, of course. Maybe he's like the ex-lover who kills his former mate: "If I can't have her, nobody will!" In this case, "If I can't be in charge, I'll destroy the country instead."


Tuesday, November 10, 2020

Inside a Fraudster's Head

 My wife has a phrase she uses to explain Donald Trump's mindset: "Whatever is not expressly prohibited is permitted." In other words, there are no cultural, societal, political norms he feels obligated to abide by, unless they have been codified into law.

I would argue that does not go far enough...as clearly there are legal restrictions he feels he can ignore when it suits him. Fraud, as was the case in the Trump University situation, is one of them--which may be why he thinks he can accuse others of fraud without supplying evidence. "I do it all the time, of course everyone else does. Why wouldn't they? Are they so stupid they would obey a law that is so easily and so profitably violated?"

This is his attitude: If you don't take every advantage, even illegal ones, even immoral ones, you're a simpleton. It's why he felt perfectly justified barging into the dressing rooms at the Miss Teen USA pageant. "It's my show, I'm paying the bills, I'll go anywhere I please...especially if it gives me a thrill."


Sunday, November 08, 2020

What--Me Worry?

 


Bells have rung, horns have blown, there's been dancing in the streets. In the oft-repeated words from The West Wing, "What's next?"

I'll tell you what I think isn't next--President Trump actually getting any court to uphold his baseless claims of massive fraud. Courts are historically reluctant to overturn elections--even the famed 2000 Supreme Court decision actually verified the certified results in Florida, even though it halted a recount. What's more, the courts will probably wait until the results in the "questionable" states are certified, by which time the whole thing may be moot, anyway.

So, what am I worried about? What Trump (and McConnell) will do in his remaining 73 days in office. I expect a flurry of pardons for Trump's minions...even the kind of pre-emptive pardon Gerald Ford gave Richard Nixon in 1974. I expect a big push to get even more conservative judges confirmed (I don't know how many seats on the bench are still open, but I expect them all to be filled before January 20). I expect an attempt to codify in law the many executive orders Trump has announced in the past four years (that won't succeed--but it will freeze an awful lot of necessary activity in both houses).

And I worry that at least one of the remaining Senate seats will go to a Republican...meaning McConnell can do to Joe Biden what he did to Barack Obama--stall every nomination, block every initiative--and then bitch and moan when Biden falls back on executive orders to accomplish at least some of his goals.

What do you worry about?

Saturday, November 07, 2020

Pounding the Table

 I guess I have to get back to politics, today.

Apparently, it doesn't occur to President Trump that the reason he can't get any high-power Republican lawyers to sign on to his efforts to stop the vote counting is that they have all looked at his "evidence" and determined that, in the words of Dorothy Parker, "there's no there there." There are both Republican and Democratic observers in every venue where counting is going on; all those observers are operating under the same conditions and restrictions; there is constant video observation of the activity, available to the public on the web.

And no reputable, non-partisan observer has reported significant irregularities. For that matter, no partisan observer actually in the room has reported such. Trump and his supporters have reached the point where, in the well-known aphorism about legal tactics, all they can do is pound the table.

You know who else pounds the table when they can't get their way? Toddlers having tantrums and autocrats (see Krushchev and his shoe).


Tuesday, October 27, 2020

One Week to Go

 With any luck, seven days and some 18 hours or so after the posting of this message, we should know if Joe Biden is our next president or if we are destined for four more years of Donald Trump.

It looks like Biden is the favorite in any almost any scenario you can imagine. At this website, run by the fairly conservative magazine The Economist, Biden is given a 96% chance of winning the electoral vote. Nate Silver is slightly less optimistic about Biden's chances, giving him an 87% shot...and also gives the Democrats an 80% chance of taking the majority in the Senate and a 96% chance of holding the House.

And for those of you who recall 2016, I'll note that Biden's lead in the national polls is now more than twice what Clinton's was at the same time four years ago.

Friday, October 23, 2020

Debate, Boss, Debate!

 There were moments last night when I expected Ricardo Montalban to step out in a crisp white suit and say, "Welcome to Fantasy Island!" Because, surely, President Trump was living in a world where all his desires could be fulfilled--where Joe Biden really is corrupt, where the Corona virus is about to fade from existence, where the polls are overwhelmingly in his favor, where black voters really do believe he has done more for them than any president since Lincoln.

The only other explanation is that he lies, knows that he lies, and operates on the assumption that with so many lies the voters simply won't have the ability to sort through them all--and so only the people who believe the lies will vote.

Perhaps most bewildering was his inability to use the moments moderator Kristen Welker handed him to change the tone and speak with some humanity. 

NBC anchor and presidential debate moderator Kristen Welker poised a question during Thursday night’s debate between President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden about “the talk,” underscoring the heightened tensions that have been felt between Black Americans and law enforcement all summer. 

“The talk,” as it’s colloquially referred to, is the conversation that many Black Americans have with their children regarding dealing with law enforcement — explaining the discrimination and mistreatment that can occur during police encounters.

When asked if he understood the gravity of “the talk” that Black parents are too often forced to have with their children, Trump simply answered, “Yes, I do,” before pivoting and attacking Biden on his hand in the creation of the 1994 crime bill, which continued the disproportionate incarceration of Black Americans.

“Nobody has done more for the Black community than Donald Trump,” Trump claimed, acknowledging that former President Lincoln — who dissolved the institution of slavery — might have done more for Black Americans. 

“I’m the least racist person in this room,” Trump said minutes later. 

https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/522393-welker-raises-question-about-the-talk-during-final-debate 

Clearly, he either didn't understand the opportunity he was being given...or didn't know how to frame a response without resorting to the empty (and patently false) rhetoric he has used to discuss race for the past four years.

No humility, no humanity...and yet something like 40 percent of the electorate still support him. I don't get it.

 

Thursday, October 15, 2020

Town Halls

 I do not plan on watching either of the town halls tonight. For those who have been in a cave for the past 48 hours, Joe Biden will have a town hall on ABC tonight at 8PM Eastern time; President Trump will have one on NBC at the same time.

I've never thought town halls were useful in the best of times (and these are decidedly not the best of times). The questions are never well focused and it's way too easy for the candidates to fudge around the edges for an answer (yes--even worse than they do in a regular debate). But I think it might be interesting to see Trump's head explode when he realizes that some of these ordinary citizens will not be lobbing soft-balls at him. In the alleged town halls he has done in the past, the questioners have been chosen by his own staff and have consisted of his supporters. This time, I assume, NBC News will be picking the questioners and will be trying for a good mix of Trumpists, Biden-supporters, and undecideds (hopefully more of the last than anything).

Are you watching?

Tuesday, October 13, 2020

That's Not How This Works....

 ...that's not how any of this works....

Remember that line from a series of commercials a year or so back? That's what I want to say every time I hear President Trump bloviate on his "recovery" from COVID. "I'm immune, now"; "If I came through it, anyone can...." and on and on.

I'm not even convinced he's no longer contagious. I'm certainly not convinced he's completely recovered, not when I observe people I know who were far healthier than he before they came down with it. Most still have lingering effects--some lethargy, some difficulty breathing. Hell, I have those lingering effects for days after a bad cold.

I understand the political reasons for wanting to appear completely healthy--but that can be accomplished without the risks the president is taking with his own health and that of all those around him.