Showing posts with label debate. Show all posts
Showing posts with label debate. Show all posts

Friday, October 23, 2020

Debate, Boss, Debate!

 There were moments last night when I expected Ricardo Montalban to step out in a crisp white suit and say, "Welcome to Fantasy Island!" Because, surely, President Trump was living in a world where all his desires could be fulfilled--where Joe Biden really is corrupt, where the Corona virus is about to fade from existence, where the polls are overwhelmingly in his favor, where black voters really do believe he has done more for them than any president since Lincoln.

The only other explanation is that he lies, knows that he lies, and operates on the assumption that with so many lies the voters simply won't have the ability to sort through them all--and so only the people who believe the lies will vote.

Perhaps most bewildering was his inability to use the moments moderator Kristen Welker handed him to change the tone and speak with some humanity. 

NBC anchor and presidential debate moderator Kristen Welker poised a question during Thursday night’s debate between President Trump and former Vice President Joe Biden about “the talk,” underscoring the heightened tensions that have been felt between Black Americans and law enforcement all summer. 

“The talk,” as it’s colloquially referred to, is the conversation that many Black Americans have with their children regarding dealing with law enforcement — explaining the discrimination and mistreatment that can occur during police encounters.

When asked if he understood the gravity of “the talk” that Black parents are too often forced to have with their children, Trump simply answered, “Yes, I do,” before pivoting and attacking Biden on his hand in the creation of the 1994 crime bill, which continued the disproportionate incarceration of Black Americans.

“Nobody has done more for the Black community than Donald Trump,” Trump claimed, acknowledging that former President Lincoln — who dissolved the institution of slavery — might have done more for Black Americans. 

“I’m the least racist person in this room,” Trump said minutes later. 

https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/522393-welker-raises-question-about-the-talk-during-final-debate 

Clearly, he either didn't understand the opportunity he was being given...or didn't know how to frame a response without resorting to the empty (and patently false) rhetoric he has used to discuss race for the past four years.

No humility, no humanity...and yet something like 40 percent of the electorate still support him. I don't get it.

 

Thursday, October 08, 2020

The Fly Wins

 To be honest, because I tuned in about 40 minutes late, I missed the fly. But the video and comments are right on. 

Pence's strategy was slightly different from Trump's. He interrupted Harris, but not as much or in the same way Trump interrupted Biden. He was overall quieter and more contained, but he still acted as though he was annoyed that he even had to be there. "Who is this woman who thinks she should have my job?" seemed to be the question in his head.

And, of course, he went over his time--every single time. And not just to finish his sentence or his thought (I'm always willing to let someone do that). He often started on a new tangent as the moderator tried to stop him...in fact, he acted like he couldn't even hear her. Add in that, not once in the 45 minutes or so I watched, did he really answer the question he was asked, but rather resorted to talking points, deflections, and challenges to his opponent, and his presence perhaps really was unnecessary.

Harris had her own moments of obfuscation, of course...every politician will. But she usually at least began by answering the question before heading off to talk about what she wanted to talk about. In my memory, Pence never did--even when a direct answer would have helped his cause. I think, overall, his strategy was "run out the clock."

Just announced this morning that the Presidential debate next week will be handled virtually with the candidates in separate locations and the moderator and town hall participants in yet a third place. I wonder if they will now give the moderator the ability to mute the candidates. (I almost think they have to...anyone who has ever been in a Zoom or similar meeting knows it's like a speaker phone conference--you can't all talk at once.)

Update: I should have seen this coming. Trump says he will not participate in the debate if it's held on-line.

“I’m not going to do a virtual debate,” Trump, who was diagnosed last week with the coronavirus, said in an interview on Fox Business, claiming the Commission on Presidential Debates is “trying to protect” Democratic nominee Joe Biden.

“I’m not going to waste my time with a virtual debate. That’s not what debating is all about. You sit behind a computer and do a debate, that is ridiculous,” Trump continued. He indicated that his campaign was not informed of the decision before it was announced.

His campaign manager, Bill Stepien, added "We’ll pass on this sad excuse to bail out Joe Biden and do a rally instead.”

https://thehill.com/homenews/campaign/520148-trump-says-he-will-not-participate-in-virtual-presidential-debate

Wednesday, September 30, 2020

Isolation Booth Debate

 Yesterday, I suggested that last night's debate might resemble scenes from a Marx Brothers movie. Turns out I chose the wrong comedy troupe for comparison: It was more like a Three Stooges short in which the director had lost all control and Moe continued to wreak violence on his partners long after the director called "Cut".

But it gave me an idea for the next two debates. If you're of the right age, you'll remember this (or if you're younger, you'll have seen it in the movie Quiz Show):




Those sorts of "isolation booths" were common on the quiz shows of the 1950s. On some of them, the contestant's mikes were not only cut when it wasn't their turn, the lights were turned off or turned down at that time as well.

I suggest that as a way to control the kind of disruptive behavior engaged in by President Trump last night. And I suggest making it automated: "Each candidate will have two minutes to respond to a question. At one minute and 45 seconds, they will be given a signal to begin wrapping up. At two minutes, the mike will cut off and the lights will dim." Why dim the lights? So the candidates cannot try to distract from their opponent's remarks with faces and gestures.

There should be no "open discussion." That merely turns into a shouting match, especially with this President. Instead, after each candidate has had his two minutes to answer a question, the opponent (who has been able to hear the answer) has 30 seconds to formulate a question (again with an automatic cut-off, so it can't be used as soapbox) and the other candidate gets 90 seconds to respond, automatically cut off as before.

Will either side, especially Trump, agree to such conditions? Probably not--but if the proposal is made and they refuse, it says a lot about how they view the debates, doesn't it?


Tuesday, September 29, 2020

The Duck Soup Debate

 Why do I have the feeling a certain amount of tonight's presidential debate will sound like these two exchanges from the Marx Brothers' masterpiece, Duck Soup?

Minister: "We need to take up the tax." 

Groucho: "I'd like to take up the carpet." 

Minister: "I still insist we take up the tax." 

Groucho: "He's right - you've gotta take up the tacks before you can take up the carpet."

Or

Prosecutor: Something must be done. War would meant a prohibitive increase in our taxes.

Chicolini: Hey, I've got an uncle that lives in Taxes.

Prosecutor: No, I'm talking about taxes. Money. Dollars.

Chicolini: Dollas! There's-a where my uncle lives! Dollas, Taxes!

 You take your choice as to which candidate is playing which part in those scenes.